You just spent three hours waiting for a table at that trendy spot only to be served cold pasta, and you’re ready to swear off Italian food forever. Or maybe you’ve been surviving on frozen pizza and jarred sauce, dreaming of real carbonara. Either way, Wilson’s best Italian kitchens are waiting with warm bread baskets and simmering sauces to make it right.
Italian Pizza and Subs
$ | (252) 991-5011 | WEBSITE
It’s 6:00pm, the kids are hungry, and you want to go someplace family-friendly but still affordable. Well, if you’re heading to Wilson and you can get there before the evening rush, Italian Pizza and Subs is reliably good. Its generous portions are reasonably priced and perfect for sharing. The dining room is also so large that you probably won’t have to wait for a table.
Armando’s Pizza and Tacos of Wilson
$ | (252) 281-4797 | WEBSITE
As a standout in Wilson’s Italian food scene, this take-out spot also loves to keep things simple and satisfying. And though most of the pies and subs all have that familiar, comforting Italian-American flavor, they’re still pretty delicious, especially when paired with a crisp slice of pepperoni pizza. Plus, with Armando’s friendly staff and straightforward setup, it’s a reliable place to grab some quick eats—whether you’re here for a solo lunch or feeding the whole family.
Monticello Cafe
$ | (252) 243-3791 | WEBSITE
No one does pizza better than Monticello Cafe, a casual Italian spot in Wilson that’s been serving the community for years. The moment you order, your table is immediately overtaken by generous portions. From the loaded pizza to the unbeatable lasagna to their famous wings, there are multiple things to savor during your meal. And the seasoned dishes here are fantastic—get the fully topped pizza and their sweet and savory lasagna, which get a boost of flavor from their kitchen.
The cozy, welcoming interior is comfortable, so it’s perfect for a casual dinner with family.
Pinos Pizza
$ | (252) 265-0600 | WEBSITE
Open for lunch and dinner, Pino’s Pizza in Wilson always has your back as long as you’re okay with simple, satisfying comfort food (it’s casual dining only) and don’t mind a cozy, no-frills atmosphere (it’s family-friendly through and through). True to its name, the Pinos Special pizza is what you’re here for. It’s topped with fresh ingredients, and loaded with so much flavor no slice is safe from disappearing quickly—and that’s how it should be.
This clean, welcoming spot also has solid stromboli with great marinara sauce, alfredo, cheese steaks, and even French fries, if one pizza isn’t enough to satisfy your craving for a hearty, delicious meal.
Pizza Inn
$ | (252) 291-2105 | WEBSITE
Pizza Inn is a popular Italian restaurant in Wilson that’s open for both dinner and breakfast buffets. This place is good for both families and casual dining, and has a friendly, attentive staff that makes it a great spot for a meal. We’re big fans of the delicious taco pizza. It’s well-seasoned, crispy, and flavorful. The taste is so good it really doesn’t need any extra toppings (but we like to add them anyway). While you’re at it, try the breakfast buffet, too.
The game room could be larger with more variety, but overall it’s a favorite among families visiting the area.
Paul’s of New York Restaurant
$$ | (252) 291-3837 | WEBSITE
When you’re craving authentic Italian food in Wilson, Paul’s of New York Restaurant is your answer. This place offers a variety of dishes that give it that home-town feel, which means it has you covered for a satisfying meal, a family dinner, or a casual night out. The menu has its highlights and pitfalls, so make sure you don’t get overwhelmed by the confusing pricing while deciding what to order.
Be prepared for the service to feel a bit rushed during peak hours, but the friendly staff and charming atmosphere make up for it.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (252) 294-6600 | WEBSITE
Marco’s Pizza has the best pies in town and is a solid choice for a casual meal with friends or family. You likely won’t have to linger too long for a seat, but if you do, the counter area works as a handy waiting spot. Plus, you can use those extra minutes to convince your crew to finally sample the Pepperoni Magnifico instead of sticking with plain cheese.
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
$ | (252) 206-1399 | WEBSITE
If during your family outings you ever found yourself settling for predictable chain restaurant fare, then Olive Garden Italian Restaurant will feel a little nostalgic. But instead of coming from a place that just phones it in, the comfort here is generated by the reliable Italian classics being served in the dining room.
And the familiar favorites on the menu include lasagna and breadsticks—both of which are way better than whatever you were expecting from a spot with free parking and attentive service.
