Not long ago, finding authentic Japanese cuisine in Bay Shore meant settling for generic sushi rolls at the mall food court. We’ll always appreciate those early options, but today’s landscape offers so much more: from intimate omakase counters to bustling ramen shops and izakaya-style grills. Narrowing down the truly exceptional spots requires local knowledge—that’s where this updated 2026 guide comes in.
Whether you crave pristine sashimi, steaming bowls of tonkotsu, or creative small plates, these twenty restaurants deliver.
Teriyaki Express
$ | (631) 888-8808 | WEBSITE
This small but comfortable Japanese spot in Bay Shore is almost always buzzing, but we have never been happier to have such a cozy space. (We’ll be checking out their new, friendlier atmosphere under the recent ownership change soon.) They do a range of sushi options well, whether that’s unique rolls like Las Vegas and Miami, generous spicy tuna rolls, or standout California Sundae Rolls. Consider the fresh salmon avocado roll with spicy mayo—a satisfying burst of flavor and texture—mandatory.
Wuyang Japanese BBQ
$$ | (631) 619-6502 | WEBSITE
At this spacious Japanese restaurant in Bay Shore, there’s a charming traditional decor that makes you forget you’re in a strip mall. That’s a great excuse to stay a while for a feast of sizzling beef BBQ, and wonderfully generous all-you-can-eat options, with soup, salad, sushi, and noodle dishes. Don’t skip their amazing vegan chicken and veggie dumplings.
Ichiban Sushi
$$ | (631) 218-0808 | WEBSITE
For some incredible sushi, try Ichiban Sushi in Bay Shore—it’s been a top choice for Long Islanders and sushi lovers from across New York for years. From the Alan roll and Peter roll to favorites like the Cooper roll and deep impact, there’s really nowhere you can go wrong on the menu, but the Alan roll is a must-get. It’s perfectly crafted and comes with fresh fish—save some of that soy sauce for your other rolls, too.
Zaza Japan Asian Sushi & Hibachi
$$ | (631) 499-3900 | WEBSITE
Fun, family-friendly hibachi performances propelled Zaza Japan Asian Sushi & Hibachi to our list of top Japanese restaurants in Bay Shore. The spacious dining room is around three times bigger than typical sushi counters, but the sushi (especially any roll with fresh fish) still shines. The kitchen does a pretty good—and pretty fast—job with big swathes of Japanese and Asian cooking from halal meats to vegetarian options too, so feel free to explore.
We especially like the hibachi meals with sizzling meats approaching a theatrical experience, and the plentiful parking, an essential amenity for family dining.
Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant
$$ | (631) 591-3107 | WEBSITE
This classic Japanese restaurant has been a Bay Shore favorite for years, and a big reason why is the showstopping uni that’s incredibly fresh and flavorful. Each meal comes with consistently quick and excellent service from the friendly staff. Another excellent dish is the “American Dream” roll, which comes with some of the best sushi on the island. Use the cool and inviting atmosphere to enjoy the meal, which somehow makes everything even more delicious.
There’s a beautiful vibe inside, although a bit dark, making it a great spot for families and everyone.
Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge
$$ | (631) 968-1688 | WEBSITE
From the team that’s made this Bay Shore spot a local favorite, Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge serves consistently great all-you-can-eat sushi, but we’d highly recommend trying their signature creative rolls as well—like the Crazy Dragon Roll with its perfect balance of flavors, and the Rainbow Roll with its vibrant presentation. Don’t skip the sake selection either.
The attentive and friendly staff, clean environment, and fresh food make this a go-to destination for sushi lovers and a return spot for those seeking amazing sushi with friends.
koiKOKORO / Islip NY
$ | (631) 650-0307 | WEBSITE
In Islip, KoiKOKORO serves fantastic Korean and sushi dishes—including some of the best Korean fried chicken you’ll find anywhere. The cozy spot also blends Korean flavors into their sushi rolls, like their sweet potato roll with purple rice, and a galbi bao bun.
Mugi Sushi Hibachi And Bar
$$ | (631) 348-9470 | WEBSITE
In the heart of Bay Shore, where commuters hurry past families heading to the waterfront, the parking lot at Mugi’s fills up fast. Such is life, when you’re one of the area’s go-to Japanese spots. If you’re willing to navigate the occasional wait for a table that could really be handled more efficiently, you’ll be rewarded with a bento box overflowing with perfectly grilled teriyaki chicken or crispy tonkatsu, alongside fresh eel avocado or spicy tuna rolls. And it’ll only run you about $15.
Masa Asian Cuisine
$$ | (631) 620-3558 | WEBSITE
Tucked away on Long Island, this Japanese restaurant serves exceptional, sushi-focused food, in a space that feels both welcoming and refined. Even the ambient lighting is pleasantly soothing. Enjoy some beautifully detailed yellowtail and salmon rolls, gyoza with a perfectly crisp sear, and hamachi kama that has us searching for new ways to describe “flaky perfection.” Bring a group, and an appetite so you can sample as much as possible.
Miko East Northport – Sushi & Hibachi
$$ | (631) 486-8900 | WEBSITE
Just off the main road in Northport, there’s a spacious restaurant that’s consistently serving up excellent hibachi and creative sushi. Don’t limit yourself—try the Salmon with fried rice, shrimp, and mixed vegetables, or even the Yaki Udon noodles and spicy edamame. They have a wide variety of vegetarian sushi options like sweet potato and inari, and you should always add a strong cocktail from the bar for good measure.
Little Tokyo
$ | (631) 360-8064 | WEBSITE
This Bay Shore Japanese spot makes chicken teriyaki that we’d happily devour on our hungriest, most famished days—but also when our appetites are perfectly content. The food court-like setting from the same team behind the affordable, fresh concept is filled with locals having a personal moment alone with steaming bowls of well-done chicken over fresh noodles with nicely grilled protein and a good variety of veggies.
Sakan Bento Japanese Express
$$ | (631) 226-6800 | WEBSITE
This to-go Japanese spot in Bay Shore really goes above and beyond with the quality of food they serve. On the menu, you’ll find different styles of dishes (chicken katsu bento boxes, ramen, sushi) that are simply prepared, but cooked perfectly. For the bento boxes, you get to choose your main protein with your rice selection, along with additional miso soup if you or anyone you’re sharing with wants to make their own meal.
And don’t skimp on their soy sauce, which we personally like to drizzle on the sushi.
Onsen Sushi
$$ | (631) 567-1688 | WEBSITE
NYC’s standout for fresh sushi, Onsen Sushi is a clean, comfortable corner spot with family-friendly seating and quiet, decent music. They serve excellent and affordable plates of toro carpaccio and salmon tortilla. The shrimp-covered crab meat with onions is supremely delicious, and so are other dishes, like their best teriyaki and veggie gyoza. Everything on the menu is worth trying once, and Onsen also offers complimentary pieces that are lovely.
Have yours with some fresh fish, or a reasonable-priced meal. It’s a great spot for fresh sushi lovers to enjoy delicious food near Bay Shore.
Chop Stick
$ | (631) 586-8938 | WEBSITE
Chop Stick is a casual take-out spot with a dine-in option that was a pleasant surprise. With just a handful of tables, the Bay Shore operation is modest—but the food is not. On the Japanese-inspired menu, you’ll find garlic sauce that shines, salmon that’s fresh, and eel rolls that reach their full potential when paired with avocado. Order all of those things, but never skip the sesame chicken combination platter with pork fried rice.
The fried rice isn’t the typical yellow kind but a delicious dish with wok char, bright bean sprouts, and salty pork. Pan-fried dumplings also deserve praise for their authentic flavor and crispy bottom. At around $15-20 per platter, it’s a solid value for the bold flavors, though some note the containers are shallower than before. Still, when the kitchen is on, it’s a tasty and satisfying meal.
Azuma Sushi
$ | (631) 262-7200 | WEBSITE
The sushi offerings at Azuma Sushi in Bay Shore are extensive, and there’s often a line to prove it. Their California roll, fried shumai, and sushi roll special are all worth a short wait. But the fresh-and-generous sushi portions are our favorite things here—and there’s a reason they also sell their high-quality California rolls by the half-dozen.
Imperial Orchid
$ | (631) 422-2266 | WEBSITE
Thanks to Imperial Orchid, Bay Shore can claim some of Long Island’s best Chinese food. Their Peking duck is crispy and succulent, the General Tso’s chicken comes covered in a sweet-spicy sauce that pairs perfectly with fluffy white rice, and the Thai fried rice with pineapple and cashews is a must-order. Come for a family or group dinner, get a variety of authentic dishes, and pretend that you don’t fully intend to hog multiple orders of egg rolls.
Kotobuki
$$ | (631) 321-8387 | WEBSITE
The longstanding sushi destination in Babylon is Kotobuki, a straightforward spot with basic yet pleasant decor where every visit begins with efficient service even during the busiest rushes. Start with the K-Mac Sliders appetizer, then get whatever permutation of raw fish calls to you. The chirashi platter with its variety of fresh slices is a standout, but the beautifully plated sushi and sashimi selections make for more of an occasion.
At peak times, expect a wait for seats, which only underscores its popularity after over thirty years.
Wild Ginger
$ | (631) 858-1888 | WEBSITE
The only thing you’ll regret about your remarkably satisfying meal at this casual Asian fusion spot is everything you didn’t try. From the kitchen that masterfully blends Japanese and Thai traditions, Wild Ginger is decorated with warm wooden accents and filled with groups sharing platters across spacious tables.
Don’t skip the incredibly flavorful and crunchy salmon roll—paired with perfectly seasoned rice and fresh avocado—and the aromatic chicken pad thai that achieves the ideal harmony between tangy and savory.
Izumi Sushi and Hibachi Steak house
$$ | (631) 686-3338 | WEBSITE
Izumi Sushi and Hibachi Steak house is a go-to in Bay Shore for great Japanese food. From their classic sushi rolls to dishes like tender steak and lobster tail, there’s a lot to love here. Their hibachi experience with talented chefs is some of the most entertaining dining we’ve had, and one of the first things you should try. Another excellent option is their tempura banana dessert, which comes with a sweet finish to the meal.
We usually go for the Lichi Martini, green tea shots, and (more) hibachi shrimp.
Kurofune Japanese Restaurant
$$ | (631) 499-0400 | WEBSITE
In the heart of Bay Shore is Kurofune, a Japanese restaurant that serves exceptional sushi with generous portions. Depending on your preference, you can choose from a wide variety of options like special sushi rolls or Ika entrees, with the spicy ika being perfect for those who enjoy some heat. We specifically love the fresh sushi that comes with skilled preparation and a welcoming atmosphere, all making for a delightful dining experience.
