Pizza in Bay Shore isn’t just about dough and cheese—it’s about finding the perfect slice for every craving, from late-night grease fixes to gourmet pies worthy of a special occasion. That’s where we come in. This updated guide cuts through the hype to deliver ten spots where the crust is crisp, the toppings are generous, and the vibe is just right, whether you’re feeding a crowd or savoring a solo slice.
Buseto Pizza
$$ | (631) 665-4939 | WEBSITE
Buseto Pizza might call itself a pizza place, but it’s actually a cheese place. A cheese place that serves pizza. From their perfectly balanced white cheese that never turns orange or slimy, to their tasty sauce, to the friendly and kind staff, to the exceptional customer service where owner Joe makes you feel like family – this is a pizza person’s haven. And the better news is, you don’t have to know the difference between a Brooklyn slice and a cheese slice to love it here.
Just let the hungry person in your group take care of the ordering, and you take care of the rest – i.e. enjoying the aroma of high-quality ingredients that fills the simple interior.
Bruno’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
$ | (631) 968-5588 | WEBSITE
A few blocks from the main drag, you’ll find Bruno’s Pizzeria & Restaurant. It’s in a simple, straightforward space with clean tables and fluorescent lighting. The food is mostly pizza with some other Italian-American staples, so you’ll be eating things like bacon and ranch pizza and decent pasta dishes. No one will complain about the service speed here, and at least one person in your party will probably make several comments about how reasonable the prices are.
Victorio II Pizza
$ | (631) 586-5552 | WEBSITE
Victorio II Pizza is right in the heart of Bay Shore, and it’s a cozy spot where you can bring your closest friends as well as any neighbors you happen to run into. This classic neighborhood joint does authentic Italian pizza, and it’s a perfect choice for either a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. Be sure to try the NY pizza, and get some garlic knots on the side.
The Pie at Salvatore’s
$$ | (631) 206-1060 | WEBSITE
The Pie at Salvatore’s is tucked away in Bay Shore with tastefully decorated older surroundings, and it feels like a casual meal in someone’s cozy dining room. Although unlike most casual spots, this one has pies you won’t have to pretend to love. They make some great Neapolitan with mushrooms and Supreme pies, and the fresh ingredients are actually the best thing about the menu.
The space isn’t huge, but you can bring a friend and pretend you’re both eating at home, which probably doesn’t happen too often nowadays.
Fratelli Pizzeria
$ | (631) 666-0458 | WEBSITE
To get through a tough week, you have to survive endless meetings and plan several dinner options that everyone will actually like, because you were so busy working. So maybe you want to celebrate this small victory at a true Neighborhood Gem.
Fratelli Pizzeria is a long-standing Italian spot in Bay Shore that serves a menu full of excellent food that’s more comforting than half the sweaters in your closet, and it’s perfect for when you want to relax and ask a friendly server who’s equally welcoming to bring another round of garlic knots. Dinner starts at around $18 for a hearty plate of eggplant Parmesan with spaghetti, and there’s a $25 Veal Parmigian dinner as well.
Zest
$$ | (631) 647-4497 | WEBSITE
You just spent the afternoon at the Bay Shore Marina watching boats come and go, then realized you’re starving and need somewhere that can handle your whole crew. You suspect pizza will make everyone happy. Head straight to Zest. This place has a casual, comfortable vibe with plenty of space for families, and everyone can share a massive pizza or dig into their own generous plates here.
The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
$$ | (631) 686-3555 | WEBSITE
The Pizzeria of Bay Shore basically invented “family-friendly pizza dining,” which means it feels welcoming without being chaotic – you can eat a fantastic Sicilian pizza, or you can eat the best chicken parm sandwich with vodka sauce. This is the updated version of the restaurant, and it’s great.
The service is attentive, there’s plenty of room for groups with both indoor and outdoor seating, and the menu has everything from delicious pizzas and entrees like the meatball burrata hero and Uncle Benny to vegetarian options (just know that it’s on the affordable side, with entrees starting around $15).
Mulberry Street Bay Shore
$$ | (631) 665-2004 | WEBSITE
Maybe you’re heading out with a crew that only gathers for birthdays, anniversaries, or that annual trip to the beach. Before everyone scatters back to their own neighborhoods, grab a table at a classic Bay Shore spot like Mulberry Street. Share a penne a la vodka with grilled chicken in a lively dining room, check out the casual Italian decor, and pretend you’re all hanging out in a cozy trattoria, when a family could probably find a friendly server a minute after walking in.
Blaze Pizza
$ | (631) 210-7409 | WEBSITE
Blaze Pizza is from the same chain you might know from other locations, but this Bay Shore spot feels particularly welcoming and well-run. In other words, it’s perfect for when you’re craving a customizable pizza without the fuss of a traditional sit-down joint. Be sure to take advantage of the fresh ingredient options and try to take a moment to appreciate the crisp crust and the staff’s helpful guidance through the ordering process.
Amore Pizza
$ | (631) 968-8181 | WEBSITE
It’s 1:30pm, you’ve been running errands all morning on an empty stomach, and now your friends are texting you asking where to meet for a late lunch. Luckily, you remember Amore Pizza. Maybe (ideally) you even called ahead to check on the wait. In which case, you can tell everyone not to worry, then head over to this Bay Shore spot and eat some things like a thin-crust pizza, some garlic knots, and/or a plate of spaghetti.
This is a crowd-pleasing place, and there’s plenty of room inside for groups when you all arrive.
