When that craving for a wood-fired, cheesy, fold-it-in-half kind of slice hits, it’s good to know where to go. And it’s more than just the crust that’s important. It’s the sauce, the toppings, and the ratio of sunburned tourists to locals in the know. From a waterfront joint with sunset views to a hole-in-the-wall serving perfect pepperoni, these are Key West’s best spots for a proper pizza pie.
Pizza Joe’s
$ | (305) 294-4546 | WEBSITE
At Pizza Joe’s, all the pizza is made fresh daily and each slice is cooked to perfection. The Key West location, in particular, has a lively street-side vibe filled with the sounds of people enjoying late-night slices and having a good time. The seating is casual, the floors a simple tile, and there are checkered tablecloths pressed against the Formica counters.
In other words, it’s a welcoming pizza joint where no one will notice that you’ve got sauce on your chin, or that you’ve ordered a third slice of the sausage and pepper.
Sloppy Joe’s Bar
$$ | (305) 294-5717 | WEBSITE
Sometimes you want pizza on vacation. We get it, we have a pretty serious craving for that too. For a quick and honestly quite satisfying Key West pizza moment, Sloppy Joe’s Bar has got you covered. They serve basic bar food at their lively spot and the prices are very reasonable.
Of course, we could go on about how the Sloppy Joe sandwich is made and what makes it special, but all you need to know is that it tastes really fresh and unique, especially when paired with the must-have Sloppy Rita drink or a cold beer. The atmosphere is loud and energetic, making it perfect for families with teens during the day, though definitely not kid-friendly at night with all the drinking and live bands. Service is attentive, with quick and hot food delivery.
Definitely a good stop if you want drinks and entertainment after 10pm.
Angelina’s Pizzeria
$ | (305) 296-3600 | WEBSITE
Clever, clever Angelina’s. This is a pizza spot with a laid-back charm, a clear grasp of what makes for a satisfying bite, and an appreciation for solid value. From the shaded patio area with its charming turtle pond perfect for beating the Florida heat, to their fantastic $5 per slice deal that lets you customize with your favorite toppings, Angelina’s should rank highly on your list of go-to places for a quick, tasty meal.
They’ve also got a convenient location in Key West, but their welcoming atmosphere with friendly, attentive staff who are quick with a smile is what keeps us coming back.
Clemente’s Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria
$ | (305) 900-7035 | WEBSITE
While Clemente’s Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria, a Key West spot with a wood-fired oven, is celebrated for their Neapolitan pizza, it should come as no surprise that it’s also one of the island’s best places to come for salad. Their commitment to high-quality ingredients shines through in crisp, vibrant greens and house-made dressings that always taste remarkably fresh. The gluten-free pizza is, of course, an absolute revelation for anyone seeking that option.
White Street Pizza
$ | (305) 735-4449 | WEBSITE
White Street Pizza in Key West is the place to go if you’re a pizza enthusiast. As the name suggests, the restaurant is tucked into a cozy corner of the neighborhood, through an unassuming storefront. With a narrow strip of seating and a small open kitchen where the staff will occasionally tend to the oven, it feels like a backyard in Naples. The standout dish is the ‘divine red sauce pizza’: perfectly cooked crust, with a generous topping of rich tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella.
The Lobster Lasagna is another must-try, layered with tender lobster and creamy béchamel. Attentive service and thoughtful touches like cloth napkins and wine glasses make the experience even better. Reservations are recommended due to the intimate space, but it’s worth planning ahead for such outstanding quality and flavor.
Bobalu’s Southern Café
$ | (305) 296-1664 | WEBSITE
A Southern-style café in Key West, Bobalu’s has a chalkboard listing the day’s fresh catches, a menu of peel & eat shrimp, grouper, and crispy pizza, and outdoor seating that says, “bring your pet along”. It’s not just the excellent key west pink shrimp that make this place great. It’s the fresh-squeezed lime margaritas, homemade conch strips, and fried green tomatoes, paired with the pleasant music and dancing, that make it the ultimate celebration meal.
You can also request kid-friendly options like spaghetti and meatballs by asking the friendly staff.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (305) 296-7795 | WEBSITE
Domino’s menu is a tempting display of ten or twelve pizzas, varying in toppings, that are marked as favorites by regulars. When they’re recommended, they’re recommended. The Key West location is one of the area’s best pizza spots and really knows how to bake a pie. Crispy and cheesy with generous portions of spinach scattered on top, and strings of melted cheese still clinging to the crust, begging to be pulled apart.
It doesn’t need anything else, but garlic bread with five cheeses on the side lets it speak for itself.
Big John’s Pizzeria
$ | (305) 293-9576 | WEBSITE
Big John’s Pizzeria is a haven for flip-flops and families in Key West. The checkered tablecloths bring to mind beach picnics and casual afternoons, pizza is served up fast-casual style, and diners with sun-kissed shoulders contemplate a post-slice swim in their plastic chairs. Gluten-free options have reached this laid-back Florida spot, though restraint is still a foreign concept.
So come ready to take down an excellent medium pizza with anchovies, mushrooms, and black olives from the restaurant’s own oven. It’s all thin-crust perfection, a glistening layer of cheese, and loaded toppings.
Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria
$$ | (305) 735-4412 | WEBSITE
Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria is a Key West institution that screams southern Italy and comfort, given its tucked-away location down the Duval alley and its authentic Italian menu. Neapolitan-style pizza, house-made pasta, classic carbonara. The choice depends on whether you’re craving something baked or boiled. The more straightforward decision lies in their appetizers. Those fabulous, fresh, layered, creamy caprese salads are an absolute non-negotiable order.
Seaside Cafe at the Mansion
$$ | (305) 340-8167 | WEBSITE
This coastal cafe isn’t just another pizza joint. Seaside Cafe at the Mansion is a picturesque dining spot in Key West serving outstanding lobster pizza, praised Parmesan truffle fries, and classic conch fritters. Come for the pizza, and stay for the ahi tuna bites and famous mojitos, and the owner’s genuine hospitality.
