Oh, Winnipeg winters. Those are two words that make you crave something warm and cheesy – like “extra mozzarella” or “wood-fired crust.” But the good news is that there are still pizzerias where you can indulge with a few friends, fellow carb-lovers, or a fun combination of the two. All the places on this list serve exceptional pies, so whether you prefer classic Margherita or adventurous toppings, these 15 spots deliver no matter how fierce the frost gets.
Shorty’s Pizza
$$ | (204) 779-7968 | WEBSITE
Maybe you just want to eat a bunch of Italian classics and drink beer all night with your family. Sure, you could do it at home, but then you’d miss out on incredible dishes, like meatball pasta and a white pizza lovingly topped with garlic and ricotta at Shorty’s. This Winnipeg pizza spot has several kid-friendly tables spaced out in its dining room and you should keep it in mind for a casual, chill family dinner in the area.
Niakwa Pizza•mcleod
$$ | (204) 661-8088 | WEBSITE
Even on a quiet Wednesday evening, dining at Niakwa Pizza feels like a celebration. This Winnipeg pizza spot offers perfectly cooked wings, potato wedges considered the best in the city, and thin-crust pies with a soft base and generous cheese. During their lunch rush from 11am-2pm, there’s a steady stream of regulars picking up hot pizzas. But if you’d rather enjoy a full meal, grab a few friends and share their signature pizza with fresh toppings.
Hungry Bite Pizza
Assuming you’re craving a satisfying pizza night, your friends will likely suggest ordering from a chain. However, just because you’re looking for convenience doesn’t mean you have to settle for bland crust or skimpy toppings. Check out Hungry Bite Pizza instead – it’s a local gem serving fantastic cheesesticks, meatlovers pizza, and excellent vegetarian options in Winnipeg.
If you’d prefer a quick meal, opt for the standout cheesesticks for around $12, and then grab a slice of their popular meatlovers pizza from the counter.
The Pizza Oven
$ | (204) 949-3000 | WEBSITE
A pilgrimage to some far-off Italian village where you can say “pizza napoletana” authentically might not be feasible this weekend, but The Pizza Oven is a pretty convincing alternative. Grab a table in the warm and inviting dining room for lunch or dinner, and share a veggie pizza or perogie pizza while admiring the big Ninja turtle up front that kids love for selfies.
This Winnipeg spot is serving up perfectly crispy crusts with rich, flavorful sauce and generously portioned toppings until late, so if you’ve got a craving for real bacon and fresh ingredients, head to their location now to satisfy it.
Pizza Fiamma
$$ | (204) 586-1313 | WEBSITE
Pizza Fiamma was the spot for a big vegetarian pizza craving when we discovered it last year and we feel confident that it will remain essential as long as people are into eating pizza (specifically the paneer variety) with fresh, balanced flavors. This is a good choice for a relaxed pizza night, especially for the neighborhood (Winnipeg locals).
Wall Street Slice
$ | (204) 221-7272 | WEBSITE
The snow might be melting in Winnipeg, but some of us miss the feeling of being six feet away from a pile of accumulated ice crystals. Thankfully at Wall Street Slice, a local pizza joint with an eclectic atmosphere and unique decor, you can pretend your birthday is a pizza day. With tables made from local Elm trees and picnic tables from Folk Fest, Wall Street Slice feels like eating in a lively cottage.
And one of the only places in the city where you can get a fresh, tasty pie like the popular Red Racer option for lunch or dinner.
Pizzaland
$ | (204) 336-3333 | WEBSITE
Thin-crust pizza that’s actually substantial sounds like a contradiction we once pondered while waiting for the bus. But it’s real, at least when you visit Pizzaland. This Winnipeg spot’s new patio offers a cool atmosphere for dining in, and their Susie Special pizza costs around $25 for a large. It’s a bit more expensive than other options in this city, but perhaps that’s what you get when you’re eating quality.
Also, wings are included in some combo deals and there’s a focus inside on using high-quality ingredients like excellent toppings, cheese, and sauce. Try the pizza called “Susie Special” – the topping-loaded pie comes with a reputation for being difficult to stop eating once you start.
Tommy’s Pizzeria
$$ | (204) 219-7499 | WEBSITE
Tommy’s Pizzeria is perfect if you’re looking for a casual patio meal where you can actually hear your friends rave about that giant mozzarella stick. This pizza-focused spot is accommodating about preferences (my friend loves the Detroit-style pepperoni pizza but needs the sauce on the side), they’re happy to let you linger at your clean, inviting table, and everything from the cheesy garlic knots to the Scotty Smokevitch is made for sharing.
Pizza Pizza
$ | (204) 957-1111 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for a pizza spot that says, ‘I’m hungry and I’m proud!’ go for the Keto crust or thin and crispy option at Pizza Pizza. You’ll have a bunch of fresh toppings involving things like heavenly cheese, addictive crunch, and that perfect balance of sauce at this ultimate chain location, and they’ll all make you want to eat pizza more often. Rain or shine, Pizza Pizza’s Henderson Highway location is exactly where you should head for a consistently delicious meal.
Vera Pizza
$$ | (204) 222-6306 | WEBSITE
Vera Pizzeria might be the only place in Winnipeg where you can enjoy authentic Neapolitan pizza with a puffy, slightly charred edge just a few blocks away from the lively South Osborne scene. This outdoor patio, highly rated as one of the best in the area, even has a quaint, slightly dated interior, which makes it an ideal spot for a casual meal out.
If you and your friends aren’t ready for several pizzas, you can also order a flavorful salad or some standout menu items like the Margherita, Rucola, or Pizza Funghi from their wonderfully simple menu. Before you make any big plans, you’ll need to snag one of the recently enlarged seating spots, or a few seats at the lively indoor tables, as the restaurant accommodates more guests.
Red Swan Pizza
$ | (204) 414-2077 | WEBSITE
Here’s a great way to spend your evening: eat the best pizza in the city. If ridiculously good Alfredo chicken and donair toppings aren’t enough, then head to Red Swan Pizza for sesame seed crust pizza for the main event.
Pizzeria Gusto
$$$ | (204) 944-8786 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for somewhere in Winnipeg you can reserve ahead of time, consider this pizzeria with its trendy patio. You can call or visit their website to book an outdoor table for anywhere from four to eight people. As a bonus, Pizzeria Gusto has a lively atmosphere that’s perfect for a night out, especially since it’s within walking distance for local residents.
Pizza Hut
$$ | (204) 953-4129 | WEBSITE
Pizza Hut feels like a budget-friendly pizza party, with lots of families grabbing hot takeout orders and sharing daily specials under $17 in a convenient spot with plenty of free parking. The party doesn’t quite spill into the dining room since it’s takeout only, but they do have a bunch of nearby restaurants and retail stores in the Northgate shopping center.
Gondola Pizza Restaurant
$ | (204) 661-2441 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for a cozy pizza spot in Winnipeg, default to Gondola Pizza Restaurant. The pizza is better than your average pie (with an amazing perogy pizza), but the reason to come here is the nostalgic atmosphere. There’s tons of charm, and wheelchair accessibility for easy dining.
Triple C Pizzeria
$$ | (204) 885-9453 | WEBSITE
If your happy place is a counter where you can grab a perfect pizza after a long day – or really anywhere it would be acceptable to live on a diet of pizza alone – have your next meal at Triple C Pizzeria. Gone are the days of waiting in long lines for mediocre takeout at other spots. Now, you can conveniently pick up the very best pizza in the city from this friendly family-run shop without worrying about parking or slow service.
