How do you distinguish the merely adequate sandwiches of Hillsboro from the truly extraordinary? Is it the crunch of the bread, the harmony of the fillings, or the perfect ratio of condiments? To settle this delicious debate, we’ve sampled more subs, hoagies, and stacked creations than any reasonable person should. From the city’s countless delis and cafes, these eight sandwich shops rise above the rest.
Potbelly
$ | (503) 840-6895 | WEBSITE
What To Know: The sandwiches at Potbelly are always fresh, never soggy. And while the space is cozy inside, the welcoming atmosphere and good music make it comfortable, so you won’t feel rushed to finish your meal standing up.
Which Wich Superior Sandwiches
$ | (971) 777-8870 | WEBSITE
What To Know: Having launched its customizable sandwich concept in 2003, Which Wich is one of the newer chains but they brought the personalized ordering experience (where customers write down their preferred fillings on paper bags) to prominence. There are multiple locations, but the Hillsboro one offers the Sandwich of the Day for just $7 every day.
Corner Bakery Cafe
$ | (503) 536-2375 | WEBSITE
What To Know: This cozy cafe opened in 2026 and is one of the best sandwich spots in Hillsboro. It has a laid-back dining space with lovely decor and is a great option if you don’t want to spend $12 for a panini at a fancier restaurant.
Jersey Mike’s Subs
$ | (503) 746-4412 | WEBSITE
What To Know: This reliable chain location in Hillsboro offers fresh sliced meats for great sandwiches, along with Stubborn soda options and a clean dining room. The staff are friendly and helpful, often assisting customers in choosing the perfect sandwich and providing fast service. While some find prices on the higher side for a quick bite, many enjoy the classic Mike’s Way sandwich and the welcoming atmosphere created by the team.
Big Town Hero
$ | (971) 384-2175 | WEBSITE
What To Know: This (long-standing) Hillsboro sandwich institution is not for Subway purists, but for the discerning. They use fresh ingredients like turkey, avocado, and meatballs, and have straightforward offerings, like the ‘one meat’ sandwich or classic subs. The bread is soft and well-made, elevating even simple combinations. While the interior remains somewhat dingy, the owner has cleaned up the dining room, making it more inviting for a quick bite.
Service is friendly and exceptional, with staff going above and beyond—a welcome change. Sandwiches are a bit pricey, but worth it for the quality, especially the praised meatball sub. Hours are limited, which might deter dine-in, but the convenient location near a grocery store makes it a reliable go-to. Overall, it’s a step above chain shops, offering fresh, delicious sandwiches in a no-frills, honest setting.
The Meating Place Cafe
$ | (503) 533-0624 | WEBSITE
What To Know: The Meating Place Cafe is a bustling spot with a steady stream of customers, often with a wait due to its popularity. It opened in 2020, accepts cards, and looks like a cozy, unpretentious neighborhood joint that’s always packed.
Subway
$ | (503) 259-9166 | WEBSITE
What To Know: The sandwich chain launched in 1965, this Hillsboro location opened years ago, and now Subway is a global franchise. It’s a neighborhood-friendly spot with plenty of indoor seating and convenient parking, but it’s reliable. The veggie patty wrap is a standout, and deals like buy one get one free make it worthwhile. Employees here are quick, helpful, and organized—much better than other locations. They even offer a free cookie to kids, which adds a nice touch.
The sweet onion chicken on Italian herb and cheese with extra sauce is another highlight. While prices have crept up slightly, Subway continues to satisfy with its fresh, healthier options, and it’s noted as LGBT friendly. No long lines here, making visits pleasant.
Jimmy John’s
$ | (503) 547-2977 | WEBSITE
What To Know: This modern sandwich shop (where you order at the counter or through the drive-thru) has been serving Hillsboro for years. The super fast, friendly service represents the exceptional care they provide, especially for customers with food allergies. The fresh, delicious sandwiches like the number 2 roast beef and the giant #7 spicy Italian come on bread that holds up perfectly without getting messy.
The professional, well-run establishment maintains consistent quality whether you’re dining in or using the popular drive-thru with its equally fast and friendly staff.
