Finding great seafood in Bay Shore can leave you feeling like you’re settling for fish sticks while others feast on lobster rolls. That’s why we’ve compiled this list of the best seafood spots—from classic clam shacks to upscale oyster bars.
Victorio’s Pizza
$ | (631) 665-3193 | WEBSITE
There are plenty of restaurants serving great Italian food around Bay Shore, but this one also serves exceptional pizza. Whether you grab a quick regular slice with its perfect cheese to sauce ratio, or you settle in for a comforting plate of chicken Alfredo to share with family, you’ll soon see that this welcoming spot has all the makings of a place you’ll want to visit regularly.
The Shack
$ | WEBSITE
The Shack is the kind of place you glimpse from the boardwalk or a passing car, and instantly crave to be there. This beachside spot in Bay Shore is vibrant in the best way—live music, clinking glasses, and punchy rum-spiked cocktails. Order the home-cooked seafood and the expertly crafted drinks, and know you’ll return again, very soon.
Le Dock
$$$ | (631) 583-5200 | WEBSITE
The seafood at Le Dock on Fire Island is some of the best in Bay Shore. Korean fried chicken is served with exceptional crispness, alongside sushi on crispy rice or penne vodka with lobster. Persevere for a seat at the bar—these excellent dishes are best enjoyed freshly prepared, while watching the sunset view during happy hour. If you want it to takeout, their Fire Island location is better.
Brazas Restaurant & Bar
Seafood spots with generous portions and family-friendly vibes are rare finds. But this place in Bay Shore offers massive plates of perfectly cooked seafood, has convenient parking, and delivers quick, attentive service as a bonus. Servings of their delicious seafood dishes are enormous, and the bar area’s specialty cocktails are the kind of refreshing treat we crave after a long week.
Not every bite is flawless, but there’s more than enough great food and pleasant atmosphere for an excellent casual outing.
Xing Wang Kitchen
$ | (631) 667-1888 | WEBSITE
The hot, fresh seafood dishes from Xing Wang Kitchen are something we crave every time we’re anywhere near Bay Shore. It’s not the only thing from this small, simple restaurant we’re obsessed with. The vegetarian options are so much better than any takeout we’ve ever tried. The kind employees, budget-friendly prices, and impressive flavors make it somewhere where we’ve quickly become regulars for takeout.
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering
$$ | (631) 665-6262 | WEBSITE
We’re pretty sure that if you break Captain Bills down into ingredients, it goes something like this: three parts delicious seafood, two parts waterfront marina views, and 20 parts friendly service. We’re talking linguini with shrimp and lobster, Lobster Bisque, and Sautéed LI Flounder. And if that isn’t enough to get you to this Bay Shore spot, then let us introduce you to the Sunday Brunch too. Sibling restaurant Captain Bills Catering, on site, is a great shout too.
Fatfish
$$$ | (631) 666-2899 | WEBSITE
You might think the servers rushing to seat you at Fatfish have mistaken you for a special occasion. They haven’t. That’s just the standard at this waterfront gem. Outside it’s all sunset views and ceviche being shared. Come with friends to sample everything from the empanadas to the halibut special, and save it for a romantic evening—a meal here doesn’t come cheap.
Nicky’s Clam Bar
$$ | (631) 665-6621 | WEBSITE
Nicky’s Clam Bar is one of our favourite places to get fresh seafood in Bay Shore. In fact, it’s one of our favourite seafood spots full stop. Just like the original tucked behind the ferry parking lot, this hidden gem has an effortlessly charming energy. The service is wonderfully friendly, the steamers are the place to start, and the fried oysters are covered in praise. The sweet, delicious, fabulous steamers and soft shell crabs are a must-order.
Salt & Barrel
$$$ | (631) 647-8818 | WEBSITE
Like stumbling upon a hidden gem in a bustling town, a dinner at Salt & Barrel feels like uncovering a coastal treasure. Tucked away in Bay Shore, this seafood spot is cozy but captivating. There’s a menu of superb options, from delicate tuna tartare tacos with a bright citrus finish, to rich crab gnocchi in a creamy herb sauce. We could also rave about the happy hour specials or the exceptional service, but you’ll come back for the sensational food.
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen
$ | (631) 666-4621 | WEBSITE
A fat piece of chicken in a sandwich, crispy seasoned fries, and that signature Louisiana spice are just some of the satisfyingly messy things you can find at this mall-based Bay Shore spot. Popeyes’ menu has a ‘chicken sandwich’ which very much speaks our language. Get it with the large fry and make sure you also appreciate the fast service and convenient location. Basically, arrive with a coupon.
Mi Campo Deli
$ | (631) 647-8410 | WEBSITE
Whether you come to Mi Campo Deli for a quick breakfast bite, or a leisurely, comforting lunch, you’ll have a good time. Whether that’s because of the friendly staff who always make you feel welcome, or it’s the inevitable desire to savor every last bite once you step inside this warm and well-lit spot, it doesn’t really matter. It’s a bit of both, and that’s what makes this Dominican deli so special.
Plus, the clean, inviting atmosphere, the delicious bacon egg & cheese sandwich, and the perfectly brewed coffee that are a cause for satisfaction in and of themselves.
Tiki Joe’s at Captree Boat Basin
$$ | (631) 333-1063 | WEBSITE
Open since 2020, Tiki Joe’s at Captree Boat Basin is an always-lively seafood spot in Bay Shore. You can depend on it for fabulous back clams, being a place to bring friends when one of them has a new-found obsession with the Tiki Joe burger, and for family meals where delicious signature cocktails are passed around and stunning indoor seating is fought over.
Chowder Bar
$$ | (631) 665-9859 | WEBSITE
Chowder Bar is a cosy seafood spot in Bayshore where bowls of creamy clam chowder and rich seafood bisque disappear fast, and families lean in over spinach salad and pecan crusted talapia to share stories. It’s welcoming, it’s lively, and best enjoyed with three friends, an outdoor seat, and zero restraint on the dessert specials.
Food King Chinese Kitchen
$ | (631) 665-2286 | WEBSITE
Food King Chinese Kitchen is a compelling reason to navigate Bay Shore’s streets. Whether you dine in, take out, or enjoy it at home, their Chinese classics rank among the area’s most satisfying. The crispy egg rolls are hot and fresh, and the main dishes are reliably tasty and generously portioned—our go-to is the perfectly balanced sesame chicken.
Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida
$$ | (631) 231-4467 | WEBSITE
Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida is a lively restaurant with a Spanish flair in Bay Shore where the calamari is crispy, the arroz con pollo comes in generous portions, and everyone looks like they’ve just come from a sunny coastal getaway. The bar area is all relaxed charm and welcoming corners that are perfect for gatherings, and while you’re really here for the cool vibes, the seafood delivers too.
Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar
$$ | (631) 206-0420 | WEBSITE
Younger sibling to the Bay Shore seafood scene, Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar is a hidden gem location that requires some navigation to find. But it’s absolutely worth it, because the welcoming atmosphere includes things like live music that should be studied for its energy, friendly staff making it perfect for social gatherings, and a lobster roll that is one of the best dishes in Bay Shore. If you can’t get a table inside, know that the overall experience is memorable, enjoyable, and very charming.
If it’s simply too far east, know that the other seafood spots in the area are excellent alternatives.
Seaside Sally’s Shack
$ | (631) 647-9293 | WEBSITE
This lively waterfront spot in Bay Shore has a welcoming vibe that goes far beyond its phenomenal wings with dry rub and frozen drinks. The staff is great, families flock to the kid-friendly playground and sprinklers, and diners enjoy the beautiful water views that make every meal memorable. Live music fills the air on weekends when weather permits, creating an ambiance that feels both festive and relaxed.
The pricing is very reasonable, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking a fun, family-friendly experience with delicious food and a stunning setting.
