Trying to track every seafood spot in Durham would leave you swimming in confusion. So let this list be your compass. These are the 18 establishments that show the most promise—though we can’t vouch for those we haven’t tasted yet. Dive in as a pioneer, or simply follow our guide to the freshest catches we’ve tried and loved.
Sho Nuff Seafood
$ | (919) 972-9212 | WEBSITE
Following in the footsteps of our favorite seafood spots in Durham, Sho Nuff Seafood is a must-visit destination. The former food truck, which makes some of the best fried shrimp in town, can now be found at 1104 Broad Street. Don’t miss the garlic crabs.
J & J Fish & Chicken
$ | (919) 598-6000 | WEBSITE
Operating out of a clean and organized storefront, J & J Fish & Chicken is a seafood spot set up in a small parking lot in Durham. You’ll find all the classic fried fish and chicken meals here, but the real standouts are the signature combos like the Flounder with popcorn shrimp, which some say rivals pricier seafood restaurants. The Polish and spicy shrimp box also shine with their great seasoning.
While the strawberry cake can be dry, and the shrimp quality varies day to day, the friendly staff and affordable prices—most combos run $12-$18—make it worth the occasional wait during the lunch rush. Just watch for bones in the fried trout.
Big T’s Fry Fish
$ | (919) 908-9039 | WEBSITE
From the folks who’ve taken over the operation, Big T’s Fry Fish is a seafood spot in Durham that’s seen some changes under new management. Unlike some of the flashier restaurants in the area that focus on fancy presentations, here the food is straightforward fried seafood, with all the classics done right. The shrimp po’ boy comes loaded up with shrimp at a great price-to-quantity ratio, making it a solid choice.
They don’t take reservations, so swing by during off-hours or be ready to grab one of the simple tables in the friendly, no-frills dining area while you wait for your order.
Bonefish Grill
$$ | (919) 248-2906 | WEBSITE
Bonefish Grill has been our go-to seafood spot in Durham for a couple of years, and they continue to deliver a consistently enjoyable dining experience. The restaurant offers friendly and efficient service from attentive servers like Shelby and Mara, who are noted for their professionalism and warm personalities.
Signature items such as the bread with oil and bang-bang shrimp remain popular among guests, while dishes like scallops on Mexican street corn and cod imperial showcase their culinary creativity. The atmosphere is generally pleasant, though it can vary by location, with some spots occasionally dealing with minor issues like flies. Overall, the fresh seafood—including options like sea bass and blackened ahi tuna—and reliable service make it a solid choice for seafood enthusiasts in the area.
Saltbox Seafood Joint
$$ | (919) 237-3499 | WEBSITE
Joining Durham’s growing list of top seafood restaurants, Saltbox Seafood Joint offers a fresh takeout experience out of a local favorite spot. Prices are around $30 for dinner plates and $20 for lunch specials. In addition to the popular oyster plate, crabcake plate, and shrimp roll, the menu has fried flounder, scallops, crispy potatoes, and more.
Skrimp Shack
$ | (984) 219-6936 | WEBSITE
Here’s a sentence we never thought we’d write: Skrimp Shack is a Durham seafood spot inspired by coastal shacks of the Carolina coast. It’s located in a clean, comfortable space with spaced-out seating for a relaxed counter service experience. There’s both classic and family-sized portions available, plus a menu of po’ boys, fried seafood plates, and homemade desserts like banana pudding and strawberry shortcake.
Parizade
$$ | (919) 286-9712 | WEBSITE
From the team behind some of Durham’s most beloved dining spots, Parizade is a beautiful restaurant specializing in Persian cuisine. Expect to find things like standout steak, wild berry cheesecake, and pork chops with bacon jam on the menu. The lamb chops and red pepper feta make for delightful appetizers, while the roasted beets are also really good. The atmosphere is great, though some find the lighting a bit dim.
Salads are served separately, and while there have been occasional mix-ups with orders, the dressing is consistently praised. Servers like Raymond provide excellent service, making it a suitable choice for both casual dinners and special occasions. The ribeye may be fatty for some, but overall, Parizade impresses with delicious food and attentive staff.
Piney Point Grill and Seafood Bar
$$ | (919) 361-4660 | WEBSITE
Still can’t get into those fancy seafood spots? Try this lively Durham newcomer with a welcoming vibe. It has a similar appeal—fresh seafood, American classics, and impressively fun drink specials—but doesn’t (yet) require waiting forever for a table. The bar service is great, and the atmosphere caters to everyone from business travelers to college football fans, making it a social and enjoyable dining experience.
Carrabba’s Italian Grill
$$ | (919) 401-5950 | WEBSITE
Carrabba’s Italian Grill is the new Italian dining destination—this restaurant is located right in the heart of Durham’s culinary scene. Its focus is “authentic Italian comfort,” which means warm lighting and lots of Pasta Primavera and Cesar Salad. They’ll have consistently friendly and attentive service every day they’re open, with staff who are knowledgeable about the menu and accommodating of dietary restrictions.
The food is generally good, though some dishes could use more sauce or bolder flavors, but the positive experience with the service, including the manager and servers, makes customers consider returning.
The Seafood Box
$ | (984) 710-6676 | WEBSITE
The Seafood Box first opened a few years back as a humble spot in Durham and immediately won our hearts—it’s home to some of the single best fried fish in the city. Now it’s become a must-visit destination for seafood lovers. Grab a plate of their perfectly cooked southern fried fish with fresh-made coleslaw and mac and cheese, or just let their flavorful chicken sandwich be the star of your meal.
The excellent service and home-cooked touch make every visit satisfying, leaving you already planning your next trip back.
M Sushi
$$$ | (919) 908-9266 | WEBSITE
M Sushi is home to some of the best sushi in Durham, and for the last few years they’ve been operating out of their sleek downtown location. They’re still in the same spot, but now they’ve refined what was already an exceptional experience, which means a consistently superb omakase course, accommodating substitutions upon request, and an attentive staff to help turn dinner into a memorable occasion.
Monterrey mexican restaurant
$ | (919) 797-0045 | WEBSITE
Monterrey Mexican Restaurant first opened their Durham location a few years ago, and now they’ve become one of the area’s best seafood spots. Expect to find the same fresh and delicious food, including chorizo queso, birria quesadilla with consomme, and steak fajita quesadilla. The chips and salsa are highly recommended, with some praising the spicy sauce served with chips. The service is excellent, with attentive and friendly servers who are knowledgeable about the menu.
The atmosphere is great, featuring black tufted leather booths and artwork, making it a pleasant place to dine. It’s wheelchair accessible with handicapped parking available, suitable for large groups, and provides a memorable dining experience worth returning to.
Red Crab Juicy Seafood
$$ | (984) 219-7925 | WEBSITE
Located in a strip mall in Durham, Red Crab Juicy Seafood is a vibrant spot for seafood boils. Inside, you’ll find lively music, generous portions, and a wonderful staff that provides impeccable service. The atmosphere is casual and energetic, with fair prices and a student discount available. Many customers enjoy the Thur special with shrimp and garlic butter, paired with sweet tea, while the seafood boil is a highlight, especially with the extra corn and potatoes.
The juicy seasoning makes the sauce 150% better, though some note the fries could be hotter and the Pina colada slush could be sweeter. Overall, it’s a great place to satisfy seafood cravings with flavorful food and drinks.
Mr. Shark Fish & Chicken (Chicago Style) Durham NC
$ | (984) 219-7997 | WEBSITE
Mr. Shark Fish & Chicken (Chicago Style) in Durham, NC, serves delicious food, featuring standout dishes like their Fried Chicken and Fried Okra. The chicken is notably crunchy, and the menu includes tasty items such as nuggets for picky eaters and good fries. The batter on their chicken, fish, and fries is a highlight. The food is fresh, hot, and flavorful, although the wait time can be around 20 minutes. The restaurant’s atmosphere may not be ideal, with some cleanliness concerns.
However, the food safety rating is high, and the staff is friendly. Guests have praised the real lemon pepper and mild sauce available, noting that the food resembles what can be found on the south side of Chicago. Overall, while the food is highly recommended and enjoyable, the dining experience could still be improved.
Shuckin’ Shack Oyster Bar
$$ | (984) 219-7337 | WEBSITE
Shuckin’ Shack Oyster Bar offers tasty food at good prices, with friendly and accommodating staff. This Durham spot serves fresh and delicious seafood, including shrimp, clams, and more. While this is the restaurant’s first location in North Carolina, they also have outposts in Charleston, Savannah, and Jacksonville. The restaurant provides outdoor seating on nice days, with a dining area full of natural light.
Guests enjoy the lively atmosphere and consistent quality, making it a popular spot for lunch or dinner. Although busy times may require more staff, the team does their best to serve everyone promptly. Overall, it’s a great place for seafood lovers looking for a friendly environment and good food.
Mayflower Xvi Seafood Restaurant
$ | (919) 401-9888 | WEBSITE
The Durham-based seafood restaurant first opened years ago, with a location known for its large portions and good service. Now, they’ve maintained their reputation with a menu of fresh seafood, where the Captain’s Platter is a favorite, and the jumbo shrimp and oysters are especially good. The food is cooked well, and the hush puppies are a highlight, served with attentive waiters in a clean, spacious setting that accommodates groups easily.
Despite being a bit dated, the restaurant offers good quality and friendly service, making it a place worth returning to.
Crab Sea
$ | (919) 316-1311 | WEBSITE
From the team behind the recently shuttered Underdog—and in the same space—Crab Sea is a simple and pleasant restaurant, ideal for families. Expect dishes like fresh and crispy fried oysters, perfectly crispy fries, and the seafood boil, which features tender corn and excellent seasoning. The crab legs have more meat inside and are fluffier, making them a popular takeout choice. Right now they’re open for dinner and takeout, but there’s a lunch expansion planned for the near future.
TaTaco Durham
$$ | (919) 748-3048 | WEBSITE
TaTaco Durham is a seafood spot in Durham. The menu features authentic Mexican flavors with a coastal twist—think shrimp tacos with perfectly crisp, wonderfully seasoned shrimp, asada tacos with rich flavor, and unique items like oysters. There’s also a selection of strong margaritas and delicious flan cakes for all the dessert lovers out there.
