10 Syrup Recipes For Pancakes

Posted on September 14, 2025

Difficulty

Prep time

Cooking time

Total time

Servings

Finding yourself in a sticky situation without access to your favorite store-bought syrups can be frustrating, especially when you’re in the middle of whipping up a culinary masterpiece. Fortunately, having a collection of homemade syrup recipes at your disposal can save the day.

For instance, if you’re experimenting with complex cocktails or dessert recipes that call for specialty syrups like simple syrup, rose syrup, or blood orange syrup, chances are you won’t find them on the shelves of your local grocery store. This is where having a range of homemade syrups comes in handy – not only can you tailor the flavors to suit your specific needs, but they also often taste significantly better than their store-bought counterparts.

Take maple, strawberry, or buttermilk syrups, for example; when made from scratch, they have a richer, more authentic flavor profile that’s hard to replicate with commercial products. Let’s take a look at 10 of the most popular and versatile syrup recipes to get you started on your DIY journey.

10 Simple Homemade Syrup Recipes For Pancakes, Cocktails, and More!

10 Simple Homemade Syrup Recipes For Pancakes, Cocktails, and More!

Strawberry Syrup

Strawberry Syrup

Essentially, strawberry lovers who haven’t yet tried homemade strawberry syrup are in for a real treat. This phenomenal concoction is remarkably sweet and tangy, setting it apart from traditional pancake syrups. Not only does it boast significantly less sugar, but its flavor profile is unmatched. Moreover, the best part? It’s incredibly easy to make, requiring just 15 minutes and 5 simple ingredients.

The end result is a syrup that not only tastes divine but also looks stunning – elevating any dish or dessert it’s paired with. Whether you’re topping pancakes, cakes, or even your daily yogurt, this syrup has the power to transform even the most mundane dishes into something truly exceptional.

Maple Syrup

Maple Syrup

When considering the possibility of a serious maple syrup shortage at your local grocery store, it’s easy to dismiss the idea as unlikely. Maple syrup is one of those staples that every store keeps in stock, making it readily available for purchase. However, the unexpected can happen, and having a homemade alternative can be a comforting thought. Plus, making your own maple syrup allows you to experience its rich flavor in an even more authentic way.

Fortunately, producing maple syrup at home is relatively simple, requiring only basic ingredients and minimal time investment. To get started, gather the following four ingredients: brown sugar, granulated sugar, water, and imitation maple extract. The preparation process takes just 2 minutes, followed by a 30-minute cooking period.

Once your homemade maple syrup is ready, you can use it immediately in your favorite recipes or store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to a year.

Homemade Buttermilk Syrup

Homemade Buttermilk Syrup

Sometimes, a pancake topping is just what you need to elevate your breakfast game, and homemade buttermilk syrup is one of the best options out there. Unlike store-bought syrups that often taste artificial and lacking in depth, this homemade version is thick, rich, and sweet with a caramel-like flavor profile that’s not too overpowering. Its beautiful golden color is also a nice bonus.

What sets it apart from other syrups on the market is its effortless preparation – simply combine buttermilk, light brown sugar, butter, vanilla, and baking soda, and you’ll have a delicious homemade syrup ready in under 15 minutes.

Dutch Honey Syrup

Dutch Honey Syrup

Perhaps the most obvious alternative to maple syrup is Dutch honey syrup, which offers a sugary sweet flavor without the classic maple taste. Its distinctive composition of white sugar, table cream, butter, and vanilla gives it a lighter color and flavor profile compared to traditional maple or buttermilk syrups. Not only that, but its taste is still incredibly appealing.

This golden yellow liquid has a delicate sweetness that pairs perfectly with pancakes, waffles, scones, biscuits, and other similar baked goods, making it an excellent choice for topping your favorite breakfast treats.

Vanilla Butter Syrup

Vanilla Butter Syrup

We also have Vanilla butter syrup, which is another name for Dutch honey syrup, but with some subtle differences in recipe and flavor profile. To make this particular syrup, you will need to combine butter, brown sugar, half and half, honey, baking soda, and vanilla extract. Notably, this syrup has the same distinctive golden yellow color and delicate sweetness as its counterpart, but surprisingly, it boasts a more pronounced honey taste than Dutch honey syrup.

This similarity in characteristics allows for the use of either syrup practically interchangeably, making them both excellent options.

Blonde Butter Syrup

Blonde Butter Syrup

Regardless of your sweet tooth’s preferences, blonde butter syrup is an effortless creation that requires only three basic ingredients: butter, sugar, and evaporated milk to make.

Brown Sugar Butter Syrup

Brown Sugar Butter Syrup

Taking centre stage in many desserts, syrups can elevate the taste of even the most basic baked goods. This rich, dark brown syrup is reminiscent of both maple syrup and chocolate sauce in appearance, but its flavour profile is unmistakably that of brown sugar and butter. To give it a lighter twist, you could try adding a hint of maple or vanilla extract to your mixture. However, rest assured that the syrup tastes incredibly decadent on its own merits – and what’s wrong with that?

Its greatest virtue lies in just how quickly it comes together: in a mere 15 minutes you can have this delightful concoction ready to drizzle over your favourite treats. Serve it alongside these fluffy pumpkin pancakes for a match made in heaven!

Rose Syrup

Rose Syrup

Making the most of its enticing aroma, this gorgeous red syrup is as beautiful and fragrant as it is delicious. Its incredible taste is undoubtedly due in part to the power of scent, which is often considered one of the most effective senses. When something smells truly fantastic, it’s only natural that you’ll enjoy eating it more.

This rose syrup has a remarkable ability to elevate everything from the flavors to the aromas, making it a must-have ingredient for anyone who appreciates Indian cuisine.

Despite requiring a few more ingredients than average syrups – including sugar, water, fresh and dried rose petals, kewra water, lemon juice, beetroot (or pink food color), and rose water (or essence) – its preparation is surprisingly straightforward, taking just 25 minutes to complete and requiring only the most basic of cooking skills.

Homemade Coconut Sugar Simple Syrup

Homemade Coconut Sugar Simple Syrup

While some syrups may require a multitude of ingredients and complicated preparation methods, this coconut sugar simple syrup stands out as one of the simplest recipes around. It consists of just two basic components: coconut sugar and water. To prepare it, simply combine these two elements over medium heat until they reach a low boil. Once the sugar has fully dissolved, remove the pan from the heat source and allow the syrup to cool down completely before storing or using it.

This versatile syrup can be stored for up to 6 months and adds a tropical flavor to various desserts and dishes, but its most popular application is undoubtedly in craft cocktails.

Orange Simple Syrup (Blood Orange Syrup)

Orange Simple Syrup (Blood Orange Syrup)

Creating blood orange syrup is surprisingly straightforward; the only reason I argue that coconut sugar syrup is even simpler is because you must go through the process of juicing the oranges yourself.

10 Pancake Syrups You’ll Love

Wonderfully versatile and deliciously diverse, these five sweet syrup recipes are a must-try for pancake and waffle enthusiasts. Whether you’re in the mood for something classic like strawberry or maple, or prefer a deeper flavor such as brown sugar, these syrups are sure to satisfy your cravings.

Instructions

Instructions

Choosing the perfect recipe is only the beginning of creating a delicious dessert. Before you start, make sure to gather all the essential ingredients and prep a syrup recipe that can be made in under 30 minutes.

Tags:

You might also like these recipes

Leave a Comment